Skip to main content

How to Create a Sales Competency Rating System

Sales performance improvement

woman sitting on chair with rating level stars graphic to demonstrate the idea of the importance of a sales competency rating system

Share on LinkedInShare on TwitterShare on Facebook

A well-defined competency rating system helps sales and enablement leaders establish a clear, objective way to measure and develop selling competencies. The system identifies strengths, pinpoints gaps, and ensures every team member has a clear pathway for growth.

In this article, we'll walk you through the steps to build a robust competency ratings system that aligns with your organisation's goals and enhances your team's success.

Establish a Sales Competency Framework

First things first, make sure you have a clear competency framework for each role in the sales organisation. This framework needs to cover the specific competencies required for success for each sales role - from entry-level SDR, right up to Sales Leaders.

In building out your competency framework, look at it in the context of HOW you are going to use it and rate against it. This enables you to be clear on gaps and development pathways.

Build a Sales Competency Rating Scale

Building a sales competency rating scale requires a clear understanding of how you are going to rate your sales reps against each competency on the framework. We like either a 1-5 or 1-4 rating scale.

If you want a broad brush approach, you could opt for something like:

sales-competency-rating-system-example-1.png

This broad approach is simpler when it comes to defining your competency framework and is best suited to smaller sales teams.

On the flip side, you open this up to more subjectivity on behalf of the Manager and rep.

If you have a lot of new starters or promotions, many of our customers (including ourselves) choose to allow for an ‘unknown’ category in the rating system so you can adapt it to look more like this:

sales-competency-rating-system-example-2.png

Including a ‘too early to tell’ at the beginning of the scale gives the sales rep and Manager time to build up a bank of evidence while they settle in.

This is much better than just not rating them at all as it gives clarity on their position.

There is much debate on whether it is better to opt for an odd or even number for your rating scale. The premise is that human nature is more inclined to plumb for the middle ground so end up with a lot of 3’s. There’s also the challenge of differentiating between ‘Exceed expectations’ and ‘Exceptional’. If you’d prefer a 1-4 rating scale then we would recommend you simply remove the 5:

sales-competency-rating-system-example-3.png

The above simple rating system is a great place to start.

However, remember, what you are looking for when managing competencies and performance is consistency and objectivity.

Therefore, the more guidance you can provide to both your sales leaders and sales reps on HOW they should be rated and what this means, the better.

Instead, you could opt for a more indicator-led guide such as:

sales-competency-rating-system-example-4.png

This approach requires a little more thought upfront thought as you need to add indicators to your competencies but it will pay off in greater consistency and objectivity across your sales teams.

This level of guidance for large, distributed teams is essential if you really want this to work as a career progression ladder.

This type of scale needs to be mapped to your competencies and the negative or positive indicators you want your Managers to observe. This will give you consistency and a level of objectivity across your sales teams.

Let’s take “Problem Discovery” as an example competency.

Positive indicators would be:

  • Leads with problem questions
  • Digs further into the pain to uncover related implications
  • Gets the customer to acknowledge the pain
  • Achieves a high call-to-meeting or meeting-to-opportunity ratio

Negative Indicators would be:

  • Jumps to a solution without understanding customer challenges
  • Only asks situational questions
  • Does not collect evidence of customer pain or challenges
  • Has a low call-to-meeting or meeting-to-opportunity ratio

If you don’t want to use negative indicators then simply adapt it to remove this element to correlate with the positive indicators in your competency descriptions only. Resulting in a ratings scale that looks like this:

sales-competency-rating-system-example-5.png

Align Ratings to Job Levels

We often get asked the question of whether the ratings should align with the job role. The short answer is yes, but not perhaps in a direct correlation way. i.e. a rating of 4 does not indicate you are a ‘level 4’ job role in your company. Instead, think of it this way:

The rating is distinct for that job role and that competency.

e.g. If I am an SDR, I can be rated a 5 for the requirements of ‘Problem Discovery’ specifically for my role. When I move the role to a ‘Strategic SDR’, the competency remains the same but the indicators change, therefore my rating is then changes to apply to the new requirements:

sales-competency-rating-system-example-6.png

Approaching your ratings by job levels this way has a positive impact on your career progression frameworks.

You can now set minimum ratings to enable you to complete your promotion pathway, e.g. as a current SDR, you must be rated a ‘4’ to be considered for promotion to a Strategic SDR.

Taking the time to build your competency framework and set out the expectations for each role, alongside choosing the right rating system for your business will pay dividends.

You’ll get consistency and a greater degree of objectivity meaning you can scale confidently across the whole team.

You’ll understand exactly where the gaps are and can create structured, automated pathways to support your reps on their development journeys.

Share on LinkedInShare on TwitterShare on Facebook
Abstract mountain with data mapping signifying sales metrics connecting sales behaviors

White Paper: From Insight to Impact - Harnessing Behaviour Analytics for Sales Growth

Learn how to harness behaviour analytics for sales growth by overcoming the challenge of connecting sales performance metrics to specific behaviours.

Download

Additional Sales Enablement Resources

a customer success manager meeting with a group of clients - shaking hands because the group just improved their relationship.

3 Proven Strategies for Effective Customer Success Enablement: Boost Retention and Growth

Discover how to enhance your Customer Success Enablement with key strategies for defining competencies, continuous learning, and aligning training with the customer lifecycle. Learn how to boost retention, improve CSM effectiveness, and drive long-term growth for your organisation. Explore actionable insights and best practices to elevate your CS programme.

Blog

woman sitting on chair with rating level stars graphic to demonstrate the idea of the importance of a sales competency rating system

How to Create a Sales Competency Rating System

Discover the key steps to building a sales competency rating system that drives consistency through objectivity. Learn about rating scales, performance indicators, and aligning competencies with job roles to enhance sales team development and career progression.

Blog

picture of a city skyline from the perspective of a person looking up from the street

LexisNexis Makes the Buying Experience their Differentiator

Learn how LexisNexis' partnership with Richardson helped them make the buying experience their differentiator.

diverse group of smiling business persons shaking hands in modern office lobby

Sales Engagement vs. Sales Enablement: Finding The Winning Formula

Explore the pivotal distinctions between sales enablement and sales engagement. Elevate your sales strategy, empower your reps, and drive revenue growth with insights from our comprehensive guide.

Article

two sales enablement professionals outlining their sales enablement framework on a white board with post-its

Building a Sales Enablement Framework

Discover how a well-defined sales enablement framework can supercharge seller productivity and customer engagement.

Article

buyer journey white paper 2

Brief: Enabling Sales Teams Through the New Buyer's Journey

In the brief, Enabling Sales Teams through the New Buyer’s Journey, we break down the specific selling skills needed at each phase of the buying journey.

Brief

online sales training benefits 2

The Benefits of Sales Enablement Tools for Sales Managers

Sales enablment tools help sales managers perform at a higher level. Learn about the ways leveraging these tools will drive business for your organisation.

Blog

sales enablement productivity featured

How Sales Enablement Tools Can Increase Efficiency

A Day In the Life of a Sales Rep: Advice on How Sales Enablement Tools Can Increase Efficiency and Success from SAVO CEO, Mark O’Connell.

Blog

aligning sales marketing

The Basics of Aligning Sales, Marketing, Operations, and Finance to Grow Profitable Sales

Sales and operations alignment is the first step to increasing sales. Discover how to align your marketing, operations, sales, and finance for better profitability.

Blog

creating a coaching culture

White Paper: Creating a Culture for Coaching

Creating a culture for sales coaching ensures coaching becomes a regular activity within the organisation leading to improved performance across the team.

White Paper

importance of enablement in sales training planning

How to Enable Training for Your Sales Team

Training enablement & sales training are linked. Learn how training enablement is critical in supporting the methodology taught in training.

Blog

sales enablement productivity

How Sales Enablement Improves Productivity and Effectiveness

Sales enablement is increasing common in the lexicon of the sales organisation. Discover why sales enablement will drive productivity and effectivness in your organisation.

Blog

Solutions You Might Be Interested In